Why "Just Do It" Is the Most Unhelpful Advice for My ADHD Brain (And What Actually Works Instead)

For ADHD brains, the common advice to "just do it" often backfires because it fails to address underlying executive function challenges like initiation, planning, and emotional regulation. Effective strategies involve breaking tasks into micro-steps, externalizing motivation, and creating an environment that supports dopamine-seeking behaviors rather than relying on willpower alone.

Ever had someone tell you, with the best intentions, to "just do it"? Maybe it was about cleaning your room, starting that daunting project, or even making a simple phone call. And did it, perhaps, make you want to scream into a pillow? Or just… freeze? Yeah, me too. It’s like hearing "just relax" when you're having an anxiety attack – utterly useless, and honestly, a little infuriating. For years, I beat myself up, wondering why this seemingly simple advice, so effective for others, felt like trying to swim upstream in quicksand.

Why Does "Just Do It" Feel So Impossible for ADHD?

The reason "just do it" is such a non-starter for ADHD brains isn't about laziness or a lack of desire; it's about a fundamental difference in how our brains process tasks and motivation. We often struggle with what's called 'initiation' – that invisible barrier between thinking about doing something and actually starting. It’s not that we don't want to do the thing; it’s that the 'doing' part feels like trying to push a boulder uphill with a spoon.

This struggle is rooted in our executive functions, or rather, the unique way they operate. Our brains crave novelty and dopamine, and often, the things we need to do aren't inherently novel or dopamine-rich. So, without that internal spark, our prefrontal cortex, which is responsible for planning, organizing, and initiating, just... stalls. It’s not a moral failing; it's a neurological reality. Think of it like a car with a perfectly good engine, but the starter motor is a bit finicky. You can tell it to "just start" all you want, but without that initial spark, it's going nowhere.

What's Really Happening When We Can't "Just Start"?

When that dreaded "just do it" advice hits, it often triggers a cascade of internal struggles. First, there's the overwhelm. A task that seems simple to others can feel like a mountain of micro-tasks to us. If I'm told to "just clean the kitchen," my brain immediately sees: clear counter, load dishwasher, hand wash pots, wipe down surfaces, sweep floor, take out trash, organize pantry… and suddenly, I'm paralyzed. It's too much.

Then there's the emotional component. We often carry a heavy burden of past failures and perceived shortcomings. Every time we don't "just do it," it reinforces a narrative that we're somehow broken or incapable. This can lead to shame, anxiety, and even more avoidance. I remember one time, I had a simple doctor's appointment to schedule. It wasn't urgent, just a routine check-up. Days turned into weeks. Every time I thought about it, a wave of dread washed over me. It wasn't the call itself, it was the perceived monumental effort of initiating the call, finding the number, remembering what to say, and then the follow-through. It ended up taking me three months, and I felt utterly ridiculous and ashamed for such a small thing. But in that moment, the "just do it" voice was deafening, and completely unhelpful.

Finally, there's the lack of inherent motivation. Our brains are always scanning for interest, novelty, and urgency. If a task lacks these elements, it struggles to generate the dopamine needed to kickstart action. "Just do it" assumes willpower is a limitless resource, but for us, it's more like a flickering candle, easily extinguished without external support.

So, How Can We Actually Start When "Just Do It" Fails?

Instead of relying on a faulty internal switch, we need to build external systems and reframe our approach. This isn't about tricking ourselves; it's about understanding how our brains work and providing the scaffolding they need.

1. Break it Down, Way Down: This is probably the most common advice, but for a reason. Don't just break tasks into steps; break them into micro-steps. If "clean kitchen" is too much, try "put one plate in dishwasher." Then "put one cup in dishwasher." The goal is to make the first step so tiny, so insignificant, that it feels silly not to do it. It lowers the activation energy to almost zero. My current favorite trick for a messy desk is "put one pen away." Often, that small win creates enough momentum for me to tackle a few more things without feeling overwhelmed.

2. Externalize Your Motivation (Body Doubling & Accountability): Our brains love novelty and external stimuli. A body double – someone simply present while you work, even virtually – can create just enough gentle pressure and connection to kickstart action. It's not about them doing anything, just their presence. Similarly, accountability partners or even setting a timer and telling yourself "I'll just work for 15 minutes" can provide that external push. The timer creates a sense of urgency and a clear end point, which our brains find much easier to engage with.

3. Gamify and Dopamine Hack: Can you make the task more interesting? Can you attach a reward? Our brains thrive on dopamine, so let's give it what it wants. Listen to your favorite pump-up music while tackling a boring chore. Promise yourself a small, immediate reward after completing a micro-step (e.g., "After I send that email, I get 5 minutes of scrolling TikTok"). Even using colorful pens or a fun notebook can add a touch of novelty. I've been known to put on an entire podcast episode just to trick myself into folding laundry – the podcast is the reward that makes the laundry tolerable, even enjoyable.

4. Prime Your Environment: Reduce friction wherever possible. If you need to write, open the document before you even sit down. If you need to exercise, lay out your clothes the night before. The fewer decisions you have to make, the easier it is to start. For me, this looks like having my water bottle filled and next to my computer every morning. It’s a tiny thing, but it removes one more barrier to staying hydrated throughout the day.

5. Practice Self-Compassion: This is crucial. When you struggle, don't beat yourself up. Acknowledge the difficulty, remind yourself it's an ADHD thing, not a personal failing, and then try one of the strategies above. The "just do it" mentality thrives on self-criticism, but for us, that's a demotivator. We need kindness and understanding to move forward.

Finding what works for your unique brain is a journey, not a destination. There will be days when even the micro-steps feel like too much, and that's okay. The goal isn't perfection, it's progress, and understanding that our brains simply operate on a different, beautiful, and sometimes frustrating, wavelength.

Frequently Asked Questions

Q: Is "just do it" ever helpful for ADHD?

A: Rarely. While sometimes a sudden burst of hyperfocus can make us "just do it" on a highly interesting or urgent task, relying on this for general productivity is unsustainable and often leads to burnout and self-blame due to our executive function challenges.

Q: Why do I feel so much resistance to starting even simple tasks?

A: This resistance often stems from a combination of factors: low dopamine for uninteresting tasks, anticipation of the effort required (even if small), fear of failure or imperfection, and the general struggle with task initiation common in ADHD.

Q: What if I try these strategies and they still don't work?

A: It's okay! Finding what works is a process of experimentation. It might mean breaking tasks down even further, trying a different type of external motivation (e.g., a coach vs. body doubling), or seeking professional support from an ADHD coach or therapist to explore underlying issues.

TL;DR

✅ "Just do it" fails ADHD brains because of executive function challenges like initiation and low dopamine for boring tasks.

🧠 Instead of willpower, we need external systems, micro-steps, and self-compassion to get things done.

📌 Try breaking a daunting task into one tiny, silly step today, and see if it sparks momentum.

As someone who has lived with ADHD for over 20 years and spent the last 5 years researching and creating content for the neurodivergent community, I've personally wrestled with the "just do it" mantra countless times. This isn't just theory; it's born from my own trial-and-error, countless conversations with other neurodivergent individuals, and a deep dive into the science behind our unique brain wiring. My aim is always to offer practical, empathetic insights that truly make a difference in navigating the neurotypical world with an ADHD brain.

Gear I Actually Use

Ultimate Brain for Notion

I've used this daily for 6 months - if you grab it through my link, it helps keep this newsletter free.

AWAKENED = 15% off