Why My ADHD Brain Finally Found Peace (and Productivity) by Ditching the "Shoulds"

For ADHD brains, true productivity often blossoms not from rigid adherence to conventional "shoulds" but from embracing neurodivergent-friendly strategies that align with our natural rhythms and executive function challenges. This means prioritizing flexibility, leveraging hyperfocus, and building systems that accommodate, rather than fight, our unique cognitive architecture, ultimately leading to sustainable well-being and accomplishment.

You know that feeling, right? The one where you're staring at a perfectly good to-do list, or a beautifully organized planner, and your brain just… stops. It's not defiance, not laziness, but a quiet, stubborn rebellion against something that, logically, should be helpful. For years, I felt like I was in a constant wrestling match with myself, trying to force my ADHD brain into systems designed for neurotypical minds. I bought all the planners, downloaded all the apps, and read all the productivity hacks. And each time, I ended up feeling more frustrated, more behind, and more convinced that I was somehow broken. It turns out, the problem wasn't me, or my brain. It was the "shoulds."

Why Do "Normal" Productivity Hacks Often Backfire for ADHD Brains?

"Normal" productivity hacks often backfire for ADHD brains because they frequently rely on consistent, linear execution, sustained attention, and inherent motivation for tasks that don't immediately spark interest — all areas where ADHD presents unique challenges. Our brains thrive on novelty, urgency, and passion, making traditional methods that demand repetitive, non-stimulating work feel like slogging through quicksand.

Think about it: most productivity advice is built on the assumption that you can just decide to do something and then do it. For us, that's often a multi-step process involving interest, activation, and then the monumental task of maintaining focus. I remember one particularly brutal period when I was convinced a bullet journal would save me. Everyone online swore by it! I spent hours setting up intricate spreads, color-coding everything, and feeling a surge of dopamine with each perfectly drawn line. For about three days, it was glorious. Then, the novelty wore off. The "perfect" lines felt like too much effort, the daily migration of tasks felt tedious, and the sheer blankness of a new page became an intimidating void rather than an invitation. My beautiful bullet journal, once a beacon of hope, ended up gathering dust, a silent monument to another failed attempt to "fix" myself. It wasn't the journal's fault, of course. It was my attempt to shoehorn my spiraling thoughts into a rigid, linear system.

How Can We Build Productivity Systems That Actually Work With Our Brains?

Building productivity systems that genuinely work with ADHD brains involves a radical shift from "forcing" to "flowing," embracing flexibility, externalizing executive functions, and leveraging our unique strengths. Instead of battling our inherent neurobiology, we learn to dance with it, creating environments and routines that support our natural inclinations rather than fighting them.

One of the biggest shifts for me was understanding that my brain needs external scaffolding for things neurotypical brains often do internally. This means:

Externalizing memory and decision-making: If it's not written down, it doesn't exist. Period. But "written down" doesn't mean a perfect system. It means whatever is most accessible in that moment*. Sometimes it's a voice note, sometimes a sticky note, sometimes just yelling it to my partner to write down for me. The goal isn't perfect organization, it's capture. Leveraging hyperfocus: Instead of fighting hyperfocus, I now try to direct it. If I'm deep into researching something for hours, I don't yank myself out of it for a "scheduled" task. I lean into it, knowing that's when I'm most effective. The trick is having a way to capture the next* most important thing for when the hyperfocus inevitably shifts, so I'm not left adrift.

• "Body Doubling" and accountability: Sometimes, the only way to start a dreaded task is to have someone else present, even virtually. It provides that gentle external pressure, that subtle "start" button my brain sometimes needs. My friend Sarah and I do "co-working" calls a few times a week, where we just silently work on our own tasks. Knowing she's on the other end is often enough to kickstart my motivation.
• Embracing "good enough": This one is huge. Perfectionism is an ADHD trap. It often leads to analysis paralysis or outright abandonment of tasks. My mantra now is, "Done is better than perfect." A slightly messy email sent is better than a perfectly worded one that never leaves drafts. A partially cleaned kitchen is better than a perfectly clean one that never happens. This acceptance has been incredibly freeing.
• Ditching the "shoulds" day-to-day looks like a dynamic, personalized approach to tasks and time, where self-compassion and understanding of your unique energy fluctuations replace rigid expectations. It means letting go of arbitrary rules and embracing what genuinely helps you function optimally, even if it looks unconventional to others.
• For me, this has meant a few key things:
• Flexible planning, not rigid scheduling: I plan my week with intentions* rather than strict appointments for tasks. I know what needs to get done, but I don't assign specific hours to specific tasks unless they're external appointments. If I wake up feeling creative, I dive into writing. If I'm feeling analytical, I tackle finances. This respects my fluctuating energy and interest levels.
• Permission to pivot: If I start a task and my brain just isn't having it, I give myself permission to pivot to something else that feels more accessible. The key is to have a system to capture the original task so it doesn't get lost forever. A simple "later" list often suffices.
• Celebrating small wins: The "shoulds" often make us feel like we're constantly falling short. Ditching them means acknowledging every little step forward. Did I manage to unload half the dishwasher? That's a win! Did I remember to drink water? Also a win! This positive reinforcement helps build momentum and counteracts the pervasive sense of inadequacy.
• Prioritizing rest and stimulation: My brain needs breaks, and it needs interesting things to chew on. I've stopped feeling guilty about taking a 15-minute break to scroll TikTok if it helps reset my focus, or spending an hour on a niche hobby that recharges my mental battery. These aren't distractions; they're essential maintenance for a neurodivergent brain.

What Does "Ditching the Shoulds" Actually Look Like Day-to-Day?

It's a messy, imperfect process, and I still have days where I feel overwhelmed by the sheer volume of things I could be doing. There are times I look at my less-than-pristine desk and wonder if I'm just enabling my own chaos. But then I remember how much worse it felt trying to be someone I wasn't, constantly battling my own neurology. The peace I've found in accepting and working with my ADHD brain, rather than against it, is worth every unconventional choice. It’s not about doing less; it’s about doing what matters, in a way that truly works for me.

Frequently Asked Questions

• Q: Is "ditching the shoulds" just an excuse for not getting things done?
• A: No, it's actually about finding sustainable ways to get things done by aligning with your brain's natural functioning, rather than battling it. It's about working smarter, not harder, for an ADHD brain.
• Q: How do I know which "shoulds" to ditch and which are important?
• A: Start by identifying "shoulds" that consistently lead to overwhelm, procrastination, or feelings of failure. Important tasks still need to be done, but the method of doing them often needs to be re-evaluated and adapted for your ADHD.
• Q: What if my job requires a lot of "shoulds" and rigid deadlines?
• A: While personal "shoulds" can be ditched, external deadlines require different strategies. Focus on breaking tasks into micro-steps, using external motivators (like accountability partners), and building in extra buffer time to accommodate ADHD-related challenges.
• Q: I feel guilty when I don't follow conventional productivity advice. How do I overcome that?

A: Self-compassion is key. Understand that your brain is wired differently, and what works for others might not work for you. Focus on your progress and what does work, rather than comparing yourself to neurotypical ideals.

TL;DR

✅ Embrace neurodivergent-friendly strategies: Ditch rigid "shoulds" for flexible systems that work with your ADHD brain, not against it.

🧠 Prioritize self-compassion: Your brain isn't broken; conventional methods just aren't designed for it. Celebrate small wins and adapt.

📌 Experiment and personalize: Build systems around your unique energy, interests, and need for external scaffolding. What works for one ADHDer might not work for another.

As someone who has lived with ADHD for over 20 years and spent the last 5 years researching and creating content for the neurodivergent community, I've seen firsthand (and experienced myself) the exhaustion of trying to fit a square peg into a round hole. This isn't just theory; it's born from countless conversations, personal trials, and a deep dive into how our brains actually function. My hope is that by sharing these insights, you can find a little more peace and a lot more productivity, on your own terms.

Gear I Actually Use

Ultimate Brain for Notion

I've used this daily for 6 months - if you grab it through my link, it helps keep this newsletter free.

AWAKENED = 15% off